SALEEM: How BBC views Gaza through a Zionist looking glass 16Apr12 April 16, 2012
by Amena SaleemÂ -Â The Electronic IntifadaÂ -Â 11 April 2012
Watching, reading or listening to a BBC report on Israelâs occupation of Palestine is like stepping through the Zionist looking-glass and witnessing not the reality of the situation, but Israelâs totally distorted version of it.
In this inverted world, presented to us by a broadcaster with a huge global reach, we were recently told that the besieged people of Gaza have become accustomed to the relentless violence and deprivation of Israelâs occupation and siege, while the residents of southern Israel continue to feel anxiety and dread when crude rockets are fired into their neighborhood.
These extraordinary claims are made in two juxtaposed articles published on one page recently on BBC Online (âGaza-Israel clashes: The view from each side,â 13 March 2012).
They perfectly encapsulate the BBCâs general attitude towards reporting on the occupation â reporting which, with sad regularity, lacks truth, honesty and integrity.
Published just after Israel had bombed Gaza continuously for four days, killing 27 Palestinians including children as young as seven, the headline for the article about Gaza reads, âGazans âinuredâ to conflict.â
This incredible opinion â that the people of Gaza have become used to the mass killings visited on them by Israeli airstrikes, to the destruction of their homes by F16s, to the suffering caused by near-total blockade, to the restrictions on their freedom and movement, to the daily terror of drones flying overhead â is that of the BBCâs correspondent in Gaza, Rupert Wingfield-Hayes.
An experienced journalist, Wingfield-Hayes provides no evidence for his article from official sources such as the United Nations or Palestine Trauma Centre, which produce factual reports on the high levels of mental health problems amongst the population. Nor does he interview any Palestinians in Gaza on whether they have become habituated to the Israeli bombs which fall on their homes and incinerate members of their families in order to back up his headline-making claim.
Instead, the basis for his assertion is that, while Israeli warplanes fly overhead as he sits in a building in Gaza City, âdown below on the streets the cars kept passing, the shops stayed open, pedestrians kept walking home with their groceries.â
And so, because people continue trying to survive amidst the destruction, the BBC presents them as being âinuredâ to the violence and injustice that is rained down on them on a daily basis. This public broadcaster, paid for by the UK taxpayer, denies the Palestinians even the luxury of sharing the same human feelings of terror, frustration and longing for freedom that everyone else on the planet is allowed to possess. Described as being âinuredâ to a situation no sentient human being could become used to, they are, essentially, deemed less than human.
Making the siege invisible
Wingfield-Hayes also renders invisible Israelâs five-year siege, with not even a brief description of the desperate situation currently facing Palestinians in Gaza, as supplies of fuel and cooking gas near exhaustion, electricity is available only six hours in every 24, hospitals cancel operations, schools and universities close, and families resort to candles for light and ancient clay ovens, lit with straw and wood, to cook food.
Is this because reporting honestly on the siege and its effects might elicit sympathy, even understanding, for the Palestinians and clash with the image Israel wants the media to project of a terrorist population threatening its security?
Was a desire to present Israelâs singular view of international law also the reason behind the articleâs original claim that the occupation of Gaza had ended in 2005? A written complaint from the Palestine Solidarity Campaign directing the BBCâs Middle East editor to UN resolutions on the matter resulted in a paragraph being added to say that Israel still maintains control over Gazaâs borders and airspace.
Astonishing and inept
Nevertheless, Wingfield-Hayesâ extraordinary questioning of an unfortunate Palestinian in Gaza remains in the modified article. âWhat do you mean when you say you are struggling against the occupation?â he demands of a man who does not have the freedom to move beyond an area of land measuring 25 miles by 4 miles, whose every aspect of life, including whether he will be allowed enough food to keep his family alive, is controlled by Israel. âAfter all Israel pulled out of Gaza in 2005,â Wingfield-Hayes insists.
This is quite astonishing and, taking into account Wingfield-Hayesâ failure to mention the siege which dominates this manâs life, journalistically inept.
The subconscious message this article is sending out, by denying the desperate reality in Gaza in favor of groundless, unsupported theories put forward by the journalist, is that Palestinians in Gaza are ok, thereâs nothing to worry about, you can look away.
This is in stark contrast to the article which runs parallel to it, headlined âIsraelâs Iron Dome hopes.â In this piece, the BBCâs Kevin Connolly tells us how ânormal lifeâ in southern Israel is âseverely disruptedâ during periods of rocket fire. He provides us with emotive descriptions of the âanxietyâ of the Israelis as they go through âgrimly familiar ritualsâ on hearing âthe mournful howlingâ of sirens and describes a young man running in fear for shelter. We learn about âthat familiar sense of dreadâ experienced by the residents of southern Israel and their hopes that the Iron Dome missile shield will become an âinstrument of deliveranceâ from Gazaâs rockets.
These are clearly not people, Connolly is saying, who are inured to conflict. So why, according to the BBC, do they still feel dread and anxiety and not the Palestinians? Are the Palestinians simply hardier, or are the F16s, Apache helicopters, armored tanks and drones deployed against them just not as frightening as the homemade rockets which terrify the Israelis?
Connollyâs article focuses on the image of the Israeli state defending itself from the besieged, refugee population of Gaza. As with Wingfield-Hayesâ contribution to âthe view from each side,â there is absolutely no mention of the fact that Israel illegally occupies Gaza, has held it under tight siege for six years, committed a massacre of 1,400 people there during three weeks in 2008-09, shoots from remote-controlled watchtowers at Palestinian children collecting rubble and from gunboats at fishermen trying to catch fish to feed their impoverished families, and no mention at all that Israel violates international law every single day of the year in relation to Gaza and the Palestinians.
Connolly talks about the levels of âmilitary balanceâ between the Israelis (funded to the tune of $3 billion a year in military aid by the US) and the Palestinians (a people with no state and no army). Wingfield-Hayes implies, when he interviews a man whose house has been reduced to rubble by an airstrike, that the Palestinians have brought their collective punishment upon themselves by standing up to Israel and refusing to accept their occupation.
As a BBC journalist who has been asked to step through the Zionist looking-glass, he does not of course tell his audience that, under the Geneva convention, collective punishment is illegal or that international law allows an occupied people to resist their occupation.
To do this would mean leaving Wonderland and stepping back through the looking-glass and into reality. This is something that the BBC, with its twisted, fact-free reporting of the occupation loaded in favor of Israel, seems incapable of doing. After all, this is the same organization which has declared that âPalestine doesnât existâ while simultaneously warning that to claim it isnât free is a contentious issue. And with the BBCâs reach extending into every corner of the globe, this inability â or unwillingness â is something that should concern us all.
Amena Saleem is active with the Palestine Solidarity Campaign in the UK and keeps a close eye on the mediaâs coverage of Palestine as part of her brief. She has twice driven on convoys to Gaza for PSC. More information on PSC is available at www.palestinecampaign.org.